I went with the Honda All Season Floormats because a buddy of mine said his Weathertechs floor liners for his Tahoe have begun curling. He has only had them a year and the sides curled in on him. I really like the Honda All Season mats but wish the rear mat was a single mat that covered the center hump area. There is no protection for the hump. I don't know how the Weathertech floor mats (not liners) perform.